
Many people wonder how should a Christian respond when a Jehovah Witness shows up at their door.
A few years ago, I exchanged emails from a Jehovah Witness regarding the concept of the Trinity. I am sharing this because I am sure we have all have faced it before. We will at some point be confronted with Jehovah Witnesses at our doorstep. And when we do, we need to know what to say. I think because we had exchanged emails, it allowed both of us to think about our words more carefully. For the most part, his responses had been civil, but I became annoyed when I discovered most of his comments were directly copied from their brochure. However, his most impassioned response came when I tried to convince him that Jesus was both God and Man; that He had to be God to be perfect (without sin) and man (so that He might be weak and die in the place of sinners). He seemed very adamant that Jesus should not be worshipped as God.
Here was his rhetorical response:
The only way Jesus could have resisted Satan is if he were God?
And if he were completely man, he would have SIN in him? Jesus had to be a man without the imperfection that sin imparts in order to satisfy God’s perfect justice; like for like. He couldn’t be the RANSOM if he weren’t a perfect man. Jesus countered Satan’s temptations with SCRIPTURES. Not by being God. We can do likewise, but in our imperfect, sinful, and human way. That’s why Jesus left us a model to follow.
When has Satan tempted God and expected to win? It’s absurd to think that Satan could tempt God with a loaf of bread, or that God could put himself to the test, or be offered power that God did not have himself.
He went on to say this:
Then would Adam have died if he did not sin?
If not, then death through sin would not have occured, right? Adam would live forever in paradise. But a perfect man can be given free will, and it would be up to him to use it in the way God intended: by obedience. And, to make it completely impossible for Adam to live forever, he let Satan tempt Eve and, subsequently, Adam. Is that right? Then, since Adam could not possibly resist Satan unless Adam were God, Adam was doomed to failure from the very start! Thanks, God! That is so fair!
And so the need for another perfect man to balance the scales, Jesus. He was not God. Neither was Adam.
And what was the irresistable temptation? Satan told the first lie. “You won’t die.”
Adam was free to obey God’s ONLY command. He was free to eat from that tree.
His prospect of living forever would rest on his decision. He was still perfect up until he made the wrong choice. When he chose to eat from the tree, he forfeited his PERFECT life and became imperfect, able to pass on that imperfection to his progeny, including death.
Instead, the ransom was appropriate. But Jesus had to be what Adam was not: obedient. Jesus passed that test just like Adam could have but didn’t. And Jesus paid the ransom with his life – his PERFECT human life.
For what it’s worth, here is what I said in return:
Hi [I’ve deleted the man’s name to protect his privacy],
Grace to you and peace from God our Father and the Lord Jesus Christ! I hope and pray that you and your family are well.
I have been doing a lot of thinking, praying, and researching. While I do not want to argue or dispute with you what the Watchtower says, I do care about straigtening out some falsehoods and misinterpretations of the Word of God.
At the core of things, there seems to be a great deal of misunderstanding of who Adam was, specifically who he was in comparison to Jesus. I do not mean to poke at you. I have noticed similar misconceptions even among my Christian contemporaries.
Firstly, with regards to Adam, it is important to understand that Adam was just a man. He came from the dust of the earth and God breathed life into him. Other than that, there was nothing special about him.
You mention the following regarding Adam:
Then would Adam have died if he did not sin?
What does Jesus say? “No one is good—except God alone.” Which means Adam wasn’t good.
It also begs the question: what do you believe about Christ? Do you believe Jesus is good?
And think carefully before you answer. Because if you respond with “yes” then based on Jesus’ own words, you must also conclude that Jesus is God, because “no one is good—except God alone”. But if you respond with “no”, then Jesus was NOT good, and therefore would have fallen short of becoming a perfect ransom of our sins.
If not, then death through sin would not have occurred, right? Adam would live forever in paradise.
Adam could have resisted sin only if he first also believed that God had his best interests at heart when He told him not to eat of the tree of knowledge. And if he had believed and had put his trust in God, he would have been gifted as Abraham had been gifted “Abraham believed and it was accredited to him as righteousness”. God would have gifted Adam with the Holy Spirit and the faith to overcome sin if he had believed in God. But if Adam had resisted that one temptation, it would have only have been for that moment in time. The Bible says “resist the devil and he will flee from you” but doesn’t the devil always come back eventually to tempt us again and again? Wasn’t Jesus tempted 40 days and nights? Was not Jesus tempted his whole life on earth? Do you really think the resistance of one temptation would have “earned” Adam the right to eternal life? No, it would not. In fact, was not there another tree in the garden that would have granted Adam eternal life? Wasn’t it called the Tree of Life? Adam chose not to eat of that tree. He chose to eat instead from the tree he was specifically told not to, at the very first onset of temptation.
But a perfect man can be given free will, and it would be up to him to use it in the way God intended: by obedience.
Obedience is the evidence of faith in God. And faith is the evidence of belief and trust in God. As Scripture says: “The righteous shall live by faith”.
And, to make it completely impossible for Adam to live forever, he let Satan tempt Eve and, subsequently, Adam. Is that right? Then, since Adam could not possibly resist Satan unless Adam were God, Adam was doomed to failure from the very start!
As I mentioned before, if Adam had believed that God had his best interests at heart, if he had trusted that God had already given to him everything he could have possibly wanted, and did not have the desire to covet anything more, God would have gifted him with the Holy Spirit and the faith to overcome and resist the devil. The test was a test of FAITH and nothing more than that. God did say “if you eat of the tree you will die” but He did NOT say what would happen if Adam resisted that temptation. We only know what might have happened if Adam had resisted based on what has always happened among the examples in the Bible of those who believed in God and lived by faith. And we know faith is a life-long journey, not a one-time resistance to the devil’s lies.
Thanks, God! That is so fair!
It is a sobering lesson that God is God and we are not. We cannot hope to resist sin on our own power. We must humble ourselves and accept that God alone is good.
And what was the irresistable temptation? Satan told the first lie. “You won’t die.”Adam was free to obey God’s ONLY command. He was free to eat from that tree. His prospect of living forever would rest on his decision. He was still perfect up until he made the wrong choice. When he chose to eat from the tree, he forfeited his PERFECT life and became imperfect, able to pass on that imperfection to his progeny, including death.
His prospect of living forever would have rested on eating from the Tree of Life, not on the Tree of Knowledge. And no, he was far from perfect before he disobeyed. The disobedience was the evidence of Adam’s unrighteous heart. Think about it. The Bible says “Abraham believed and it was accredited to him as righteousness”. If Adam believed God, if he had believed and simply trusted that God had his best interests at heart when he said “do not eat of that tree”, he would not have eaten of the tree. He wouldn’t even had considered it. But Adam acted like a spoilt child. He had everything he could ever want. And he wasn’t happy. He wanted more. With the tiniest nudge from a serpent he chose to eat of the tree he was specifically told not to. And just as a spoilt child typically would react, Adam didn’t even repent of his sin. Instead he blamed his wife. Where was the rightousness of Adam? God gave him one simple rule and he wasn’t able to follow even that one. If anything, Adam’s failure proved just how imperfect a man he was.
And so the need for another perfect man to balance the scales, Jesus. He was not God. Neither was Adam.
Instead, the ransom was appropriate. But Jesus had to be what Adam was not: obedient. Jesus passed that test just like Adam could have but didn’t. And Jesus paid the ransom with his life – his PERFECT human life.
Who was Jesus mother? Who was His father? Was not His mother Mary? And was not His father the Lord God Almighty? Certainly, Jesus was no ordinary man! His conception was a miracle of God! When Jesus called God “Father” He did so in the literal sense. He had no earthly father or conception. He did not just resist sin – He performed miracles and wonders no man could have ever dreamed of! He walked on water, commanded the wind and the waves, casted out demons, brought sight to blind, healed the lame and the sick, and raised the dead to life. He was also transfigured before Peter, James and John in all His glory. He claimed to be the “bread of life” who spoke “words of eternal life”. Was Adam all of these? There is no comparison. Jesus embodied all the goodness and power and glory of God – Adam did not. And as far as ransom was concerned, this was far more than a life for a life. Jesus had to be the ransom to pay the burden of every sin, weakness, humiliation, shame, and the deserved wrath of God, FOR THE ENTIRE HUMAN RACE EXISTING FROM ADAM TO THE DAY OF JUDGEMENT. All men, regardless of their righteous deeds, are but dust and ashes compared to the Son of God. Possessing God’s perfect goodness of character, Jesus alone could perfectly and consistently resist the devil. Yes, Jesus used Scripture. But Scripture is useless without the power of the Spirit of God behind it. (The Pharisees also had Scripture and it was useless to them.) As to the question why Satan bothered with tempting Jesus at all if the devil knew Jesus was God…. why does the devil do anything? Pride deludes him into thinking he can defeat God. That was always the devil’s problem from the very beginning.
You said: “Jesus would never allow humans to worship him in place of God” and I firmly believe that is a true statement IF Jesus was an ordinary human being like you and I. If any ordinary human being like you or I made statements implying he was God, and people swarmed to bow down and worship that person, we would rightfully call that blasphemous. But Jesus was no ordinary human being.
In the book of John, Jesus makes several “I AM” statements:
- I am the bread of life. 6:35, 48, 51.
- I am the light of the world. 8:12; 9:5.
- I am the door of the sheep. 10:7, 9.
- I am the good shepherd. 10:11, 14.
- I am the resurrection and the life. 11:25.
- I am the way, the truth, and the life. 14:6.
- I am the true vine
Many of these have cross-references to the Old Testament referring to God. A Christian theologian told a story once of a time in which he began to study the Old Testament with a group of modern-day Jewish scholars. A few of the Jews became curious of the New Testament and asked him if he could lead a study on one of the gospels. One day, one of the Jews came to one of their studies. He had never read any of the New Testament Scriptures before in his life. The Christian theologian asked him to read aloud from John chapter 10. As the man read the words of Jesus, he began to look appalled. His reaction was immediate when he got to Jesus words: I am the good shepherd. “He is declaring himself to be God!” he shouted. The man was so enraged, he spat on the Bible, threw it down, and stomped on it. Now, if this is the conclusion and reaction of a modern-day Jew, don’t you think the Jews of Jesus’ time would have reacted the same? The Jews would have interpreted Jesus’ statements the same way: they would have concluded that Jesus was referring to himself as God. And this conclusion would have inspired one of two responses: either one of reverence or one of contempt. There would have been no middle ground. The ones who hated him had him killed. As to the others, I challenge you to find a single incident in Scripture of Jesus dissuading anyone from worshipping him. Even the angel that gave John visions of the book of Revelations corrected John when he fell down in worship of him. Even Paul and Barnabas were mistaken as gods in the book of Acts after Paul healed a man yet surely their actions paled in comparison to all the signs and wonders Jesus performed while He was on earth. In light of all these things, is it really that incomprehensible that many of Jesus followers revered him as God? And if that is so, why doesn’t Scripture give any warnings against it?
P.S. He has not emailed me since.
And to this day, I have not heard a response from him.


